Vinoth Ramachandra

India: A Failing State?

Posted on: July 7, 2017

While “hate crimes” committed by and against Muslims in Europe receive increasing attention in the global media, the rise of Hindu vigilantism in India receives scant coverage. Yet the loss of life and the levels of terror under which Muslim and other religious minorities in India now live far exceed anything experienced in the West.

For example, a 15-year-old Muslim boy, Hafiz Junaid, was stabbed to death on board a Delhi-Mathura train on June 22. His and his three brothers had boarded the train at Delhi’s Sadar Bazar Station after shopping for Eid, the end of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan. They were set upon by a mob which repeatedly taunted them with cries of “anti-nationals” and “beef eaters.” In the fight which ensued, Junaid’s three brothers were hospitalized with stab wounds. The police have hitherto done nothing to apprehend the killers.

India is an exporter of beef. But ever since the nineteenth-century Hindu nationalist movement under the leadership of the Arya Samaj made Cow Protection a political slogan, it has from time to time been an excuse for vigilante groups to harass and even murder Muslims in the name of “protecting our religion and culture”. Cows are deemed more valuable than some human lives. Hence the term “sacred cow” that has passed into the English language to denote any object that is immune to criticism.

Under the current BJP government in India, cow protection groups, operating with impunity, have killed Muslims and low-caste peoples simply for transporting cattle. In BJP-ruled states the lynching of Muslim men by Hindu mobs is becoming commonplace.

The Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his cronies in the central government remain silent over these killings. But so do many affluent Hindu Indians in the US who welcomed Modi to the US a few days ago and who are intent on exploiting the Trump regime’s ignorance and fear of the Muslim world. A week after Junaid’s murder Modi was in Washington DC, wooing the Tech Giants to invest in India, while the country itself is deteriorating into a state of near-anarchy.

The BJP-ruled Gujarat state, where Modi was formerly chief minister and blithely ignored repeated pogroms against Muslims, recently amended its Animal Preservation Act of 1954 to extend the maximum sentence for cow slaughter from the present seven-year jail term to life imprisonment.

Anybody familiar with Indian cities knows that cows are treated far worse in India than in other countries. Malnourished cows, their ribs painfully sticking out and munching on discarded polythene bags, are a common sight in Indian cities. But anyone familiar with Indian politics knows that such contradictions are central to the whole ideology of Hindutva. Every nationalist needs a bogeyman, and Pakistan and the Muslim and Christian minorities in India serve that end.

Moreover, academic scholars are under pressure to rewrite not only the history of India but their specialist courses so as to obliterate or diminish the contribution of Muslim, Christian and other minority communities. Liberal and Marxist scholars and journalists, no less than Christians and Muslims, are often the targets of vicious personal attacks. Christian NGOs working among the poor (largely ignored by vocal Hindu politicians except at election time) are constantly harassed with allegations of making “unethical conversions”.

Yet another irony is that the colonial penal code relating to “sedition” has often been invoked in recent months to justify assaults on anybody who criticizes India’s policy or military actions in Kashmir. Pakistani actors cannot appear in Indian movies. A group of Muslims who cheered Pakistan’s recent victory in the international cricket championship were set upon by a gang who charged them with “sedition”. Such are the ridiculous depths to which Indian society has sunk! (Imagine all those Indians in the UK who, despite being British citizens, cheer the Indian cricket team when they defeat England, being hauled off to gaol!)

But all is not yet lost. Amnesty International India has condemned hate crimes against Muslims, and civil society organizations have continued to mobilize people to express their revulsion at police inaction and tacit governmental support for the growing culture of Hindu vigilantism. Several thousands of concerned citizens have marched in Indian cities under the slogan “Not in My Name”, following the murder of Junaid and the spate of recent mob lynchings.

If more Hindus in India and the so-called Indian diaspora in the West do not raise their voice in support of such civil society defiance, they should not be surprised if the fear, anger and frustration of young Muslims becomes channelled in the direction of ISIS and other radicalised Islamist groups. If there is one lesson we have learned in South Asia in the post-colonial era it is that extremism breeds extremism, and the silence of elites strengthens the voice of the mob.

Is a government that fails to protect its minorities a “failed state”?

7 Responses to "India: A Failing State?"

[…] a Christian perspective on these themes read Vinoth Ramachandra here. Indeed, every single point that Ramachandra makes in his post is told through story and character […]

This was an education Vinoth. Another passionate yet balanced critique. Thank you.

I am a proud Indian. I live in Canada and work in America. It does not help to hear how miserable Indians are in their own country when most Indians overseas are proud of the great achievement of India and its people despite suffering foreign occupation. But bouncing back to become a superpower proud and independent and sending a successful mission to Mars.
PM Midi has reduced poverty in India by half and was successful in reducing human waste.
Read what world leaders are saying about India.
Bill Gates praises India for success, seen congratulating PM Modi.

PM Modi praises Indian achievements.

World leaders praise PM Modi’s leadership.

Trump loves Indians.

India’s successful Mars mission.

Cleanest cities and states in India. 2018.

It is shameful to hear Vinoth attack India a country which over 1.3 billion Indians call home.
It is either his Karma is bad or the curry he ate which caused him to spew such vomit.

Well, if you are all so proud of India why are you living in North America? Why not go back and experience for yourself the wonderful reality of life in this new “superpower”? And you can ask Bill Gates and others you admire to come and walk the clean streets of India and drink its clean water and breathe its clean air- instead of traveling first-class and staying in the superluxury hotels.

Until Indians can openly ridicule the pretensions of their political leaders and the anti-Muslim BJP rhetoric, without fear of being dubbed “unpatriotic” or attacked by fanatical mobs, India will never be a “superpower” like the US.

I am a Brahmin and come from a very prestigious family. So it’s not like I did not enjoy a privileged life in India. Nor has it diminished my family’s status when I left to work in the IT field in America. In fact it’s pioneers like us that brought the IT technology to India, just like Indian NASA engineers were behind the successful Mars mission.
Karma is what Karma does. India is about to overtake China as the most populace country on earth. Where is the individual responsibility to control birth rates especially among the very poor?
In this area India is very comparable to Aftica. The poor and illiterate are a drag on society.
We can learn from Africans how to deal with this shared problem.
Africans being treated for AIDS and extreme stupidity
https://youtu. Be/xk2v6WyoHUY
https://youtu. Be/ecATcD9ng3Y

I think you have proved what I say in my post.

The Nazis also boasted about their technological prowess and their “superiority” to other peoples. They couldn’t see what moral pygmies they were. A lot of Hindutva propaganda reminds me of 1930s Germany.

you must be agent of congress party always try to critisize Modi

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s



July 2017
%d bloggers like this: