Vinoth Ramachandra

An Unsavoury Musk?

Posted on: November 5, 2022

Standing on the bleak platform of a New York subway last week, I was captivated by a shabbily dressed stranger who dropped a bag by my side, unzipped it to produce a trumpet and began to play the most haunting jazz I have heard in some time. I decided to miss three trains so that I could stay and listen to the glorious music.

There was something ethereal about the experience: beauty in the midst of drabness, human creativity bursting through poverty and squalor. It recalled the late sociologist Peter Berger’s description of what he called “rumours of angels” or “signals of transcendence”- for instance, the universal human experiences of play, ordering, protesting evil, defying death, and so on.

Identifying such signals in the midst of the bleak political landscape of our times calls for a knowledge and imagination that exceed my own. And I invite readers of this Blog to share such explicitly political “rumours of angels”.

In my own country, people continue to peacefully protest the incompetence and corruption of a government that seeks to suppress them by means of repressive decrees. In Iran, the indomitable courage of schoolgirls puts to shame the protestations of armchair critics of tyranny that “nothing can be done”. The complicity of banks in Australia and Singapore in buttressing the military junta in Myanmar has been exposed, albeit too late. Bolsonaro has been evicted in Brazil; but, at the same time, a far-right politician takes over in Italy and fascist Jewish groups control Israel politics. (Indeed, the state of Israel, as I have often noted, is a classic example of how people brought up on a collective narrative of victimhood can become victimisers themselves. How different are the far-right Zionist settlers from the Nazi thugs who terrorized German Jews?)

Conventional economics separates economic outcomes from political and cultural practices. Marx turned such thinking on its head. Political ideologies reflected the economic forces of production. But Marx’s middle-classes are now themselves at the mercy of “market forces” shaped by oligarchs and oligopolies. And the proletariat (if it exists in its classical form) are seduced by the new opium of sport- World Cup football and T20 cricket- to be anything approaching a revolutionary force.

The Tory leadership in the UK represents the callous indifference of upper echelons of British society and are completely out of touch with the lives of the average Briton. (In this regard they are more like monarchies than Marx’s bourgeosie). As for both the Labour party leadership in the UK and the Democrats in the US, they have long become estranged from their historic bases in the lives and aspirations of blue-collar workers.

The unholy alliance of economic and political power is shown not only by the influence of the big merchant banks on government policies (remember the bailouts of 2008?) but by the erosion of all global and domestic efforts to ensure fair economic competition and moral accountability. Corporations routinely ignore the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Western corporations have meekly submitted to China’s draconian Community Party line in order to gain access to its huge markets and supply chains.

Elon Musk’s acquisition of Twitter is not simply an economic act. It has huge political ramifications, for Musk has significant business interests in China, just as Trump’s empire has in the Persian Gulf. China is Tesla’s second-largest market, and sales in China have increased significantly in the past couple of years. Tesla’s plant in Shanghai is the world’s largest electric vehicle factory. In January, Tesla opened a showroom in Xinjiang that was criticised by some members of the  US Congress and rights groups because of the Chinese government’s crimes against humanity targeted at the region’s Uighur community and political dissidents.

The Chinese government is sensitive about its image abroad and has repeatedly targeted Twitter uses in the country. It has jailed those who criticise the party, and forced them to delete sensitive tweets or close their accounts. At the same time, they have used the platform to spread false information, creating numerous fake accounts that defend the government’s positions on Hong Kong, Xinjiang, COVID-19 and other issues.

Online safety groups and human rights campaigners have expressed concerns about Mr Musk’s plans to relax content moderation and reverse permanent Twitter bans given to controversial figures, including former US president Donald Trump.

But Musk’s acquisition of Twitter has overjoyed the Chinese regime. It has now created an opportunity for China to reshape the discourse on that social media platform about its practices of cultural genocide, arbitrary imprisonments and forced labour.

Writing in The Times of India four decades ago, the well-known sociologist Rajni Kothari lamented: “As I talk to my friends, my relatives, my professional colleagues today, I get a feeling of total ignorance of the other India. When in fact they are forced to take note, such as when they walk through the pavements on which people are sleeping, there is a feeling of revulsion, of rejection, of contempt, not of compassion, empathy and least of all of any sense of guilt.”

Little has changed since Kothari wrote those chilling words. And they apply not only to India, but to the Western liberal democracies. The insularity and parochialism of current global politics, coupled with massive, unaccountable and concentrated economic power, threaten all humanity and future generations. From where will arise rumours of angels?

5 Responses to "An Unsavoury Musk?"

My immediate reaction to what is happening worldwide is to play the metaphorical ostrich in the sand. My wife and i were discussing the candidates we are voting on in the US primary election this coming Tuesday, and i found myself either not knowing the candidates and their political positions well or the issues we vote on are so complicated and undecipherable to even two individuals with graduate degrees. No wonder only 20 to 35% of voters participate in primaries.

I am reminded of the Salt and the Light teaching of Jesus on the Sermon on the Mount, comparing His people to possess qualities like Salt and Light amid a world that is bound to decay and purification and turning dark naturally. Christians are called to countercultural living in a society that is getting bad to worse by default. We are called to live differently, not in wishful thinking but in the assured hope of a different kind of kingdom and a King to rule over us.

When I see homelessness in the United States, poverty and what I would consider economic and social despair, I am not repulsed by its victims but rather by the people, businesses and institutions which allow this to happen. No excuses.

Who gave permission to Musk current regime !! Right then current regime has to be answerable communist China coming!

A bit late to the party here but a fitting end of year reflection for an exceptionally turbulent year in an exceptionally turbulent era. One point of divergence: I wouldn’t be so quick to dismiss the modern proletariat. As we’re seeing in the resurgent union movement across the West – not to mention the tireless and fearless efforts of labour rights’ activists around the world – workers are rising up from all sectors in unprecedented ways. The current cost of living crisis – not to mention its myriad causes – have been a catalyst. As for the UK Labour leadership, I’d agree the current iteration is pure Establishment, business-as-usual politics through and through. Nevertheless, let’s not forget his predecessor, a certain Mr Corbyn, was a break with the programme by which the elites could never abide. Similarly with Bernie Sanders ultimately failed bid for the Democratic presidential candidate nomination. Hope lives on, especially with more and more people becoming politically sensitised and mobilising – either through protest and/or strike action. The question is, where is the capital-C Church in all of this? Too often MIA, with the exception of Christian activists and thinkers on the margins- such as the author of this fine blog. May God deliver us from our complacency and cowardice.

May our LORD continue to bless us all through this splendid ministry of love, honesty, sacrifice and integrity.
Very grateful. Happy birthday!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s



November 2022
%d bloggers like this: